Tuesday, September 3rd
2024 Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews
Fanatics Authentic
- Prices for MLB from $19.99 to $4,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $119.99 to $3,799.99
- Sale prices from $19.99 to $19,999.99
- Options to buy meet-and-greets
- Jersey protection program + jersey replacement
- Holographic authentication
- Returns within 365 days
- Free shipping on $24+
- "A+" rating from the BBB
Fanatics Authentic's website is a treasure trove for fans of NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, NCAA, NASCAR, and soccer teams, with dedicated categories to explore each. They take pride in offering the world's largest collection of officially licensed, exclusive fan gear, including items dating back to the 50s.
Specialized items
In addition to traditional fan gear, Fanatics Authentic provides specialized sections, including game-used items and trading cards, offering a diverse selection for all collectors. Fanatics Authentic is part of a larger network, owning several other sports memorabilia retail stores like Steiner Sports, Fan's Edge, and Sports Memorabilia. This interconnected ecosystem of retailers lets Fanatics Authentic cater to a wide range of customer preferences in terms of products and pricing.
Easy to find new and exciting options
The standout feature at Fanatics Authentic is the ability to search for top players across all listed teams, making it incredibly convenient to find your favorite athlete's memorabilia. What sets Fanatics Authentic apart is their dynamic approach to purchasing and collecting. In addition to traditional sales, they've established meet-and-greet opportunities. (For example, one opportunity included the chance to meet Jonathan Marchessault & Jack Eichel in Las Vegas.) It's super easy to find what you need with the organization and filter options at Fantastic Authentic. So, if you're looking for unique finds on a clean shopping user interface, Fanatics Authentic is a great place to start.
Full range of costs and highly sought inventory
The products at Fanatics Authentic span a wide spectrum, from signed balls and autographed portraits to jerseys, framed player collages, and even signed flags. You can choose from a variety of ways to shop including by sport, by player, by items that were actually used in games, as well as items that are exclusive to Fanatics Authentic. No matter what you need, you'll easily be able to find it here.
Price comparison
To check out the prices at Fanatics Authentic and how they compare to other companies in this review, we looked at two key items at each retailer: First, autographed memorabilia for Major League Baseball, and second, National Football League autographed jerseys. While there are tons of other sports represented, these are some of the most popular sports in the US. Finally, we also looked at the sale prices at each retailer to see which company offers the best deals in general. At Fanatics Authentic, the prices shake out to:
- Autographed MLB Memorabilia: $19.99 to $4,999.99 which ranged from a 2021 signature ball from the World Series to a Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels Autographed First Career Home Run Game Ticket
- Autographed NFL Jerseys: $119.99 to $3,799.99 which ranged from a Raheem Mostert San Francisco 49ers Autographed White Nike Game Jersey to a Tom Brady Tampa Bay Buccaneers Autographed Super Bowl LV Champions Jersey
- Sale items: $19.99 to $19,999.99 ranging from a Boston Red Socks Game-Used Pen with authentic dirt to Zion Williamson New Orleans Pelicans Autographed Game-Used Red/White Jordan Shoes
Jersey replacement available
Fanatics Authentic offers a jersey protection program, providing replacement jerseys if a player is traded or changes teams. We were particularly excited about this feature as it shows the company's commitment to the customers in the long term. It also shows that they stand behind the memorabilia they sell, which will provide collectors with peace of mind.
356-day returns and free shipping offers
Fanatics Authentic offers a generous return policy that allows items to be returned up to 365 days from the ship date if they are unworn/unused and in original condition with tags and labels attached. On top of that, Fanatics Authentic offers regular deals for their shipping. For example, at the time of this review, Fanatics Authentic was offering a free shipping deal for any order over $24. This makes it super easy to score free shipping no matter what you're looking to buy at Fanatics Authentic.
Hologram authentication
All items at Fanatics Authentic are protected with hologram authentication. Customers can easily check if their items are authentic by entering the code on their included hologram tags in the on-site checker. This makes it simple to see the proper authentication of each of your memorabilia items. Each code is unique to each item, so customers can be sure there are no companies or fakes with Fanatics Authentic.
Top-rated for customer service
Fanatics Inc. holds an impressive "A+" rating and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau. Further, Fanatics Authentic itself holds an average star rating of 4.2 out of 5 across multiple review sites, showcasing customer satisfaction. Customer reviews included praise for the customer service department at Fanatics Authentic which went above and beyond to get items to their new owners on time even during a holiday rush as well as solving problems with order errors or complications. Overall, customers feel that they are in good hands both with item quality and service at Fanatics Authentic.
Great choice for unique finds
Bottom line? Fanatics Authentic is a standout choice for sports memorabilia collectors. Their website's user-friendly interface and vast array of collector's items make the shopping experience enjoyable and hassle-free. Furthermore, their "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau reflects their commitment to maintaining high standards in the industry. Whether you're a seasoned collector, a novice enthusiast, or just someone looking to score a meet-and-greet with their favorite player, Fanatics Authentic is the #1 store for your sports memorabilia needs.
Press Pass Collectibles
- Prices for MLB from $4.99 to $119,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $39.99 to $14,999.99
- Options to buy vintage items
- Returns within 21 days
- Third-party authentication
- "A+" rating from the BBB
Press Pass Collectibles is an absolute delight for sports memorabilia enthusiasts and collectors. What truly sets Press Pass Collectibles apart is the sheer variety of artifacts they offer. While you might start your journey in search of a basketball signed by Michael Jordan, you could stumble upon a letter signed by Albert Einstein or a signed photograph of Abraham Lincoln. The unexpected discoveries make each visit to their website an exciting adventure, and you're bound to find items that you didn't even know existed.
Solid site design
Browsing through their extensive selection of retro products is not only impressive but also incredibly entertaining. The website's user-friendly interface makes navigation a breeze, whether you're exploring their diverse product listings or using the search function. Everything is easy to find with all their selections on the top navigation bar as well as solid filters during browsing.
Huge range of items for all budgets
From football and baseball to basketball, NCAA, the Olympics, and even presidential and celebrity memorabilia, Press Pass Collectibles has it all. Each category offers a wealth of jerseys, magazines, photographs, books, apparel, posters, and other relevant gear. When it comes to pricing, it's often challenging to determine fairness, especially when dealing with memorabilia that holds immense sentimental value. Press Pass Collectibles offers a range of items that cater to different budgets.
Price comparison
To compare pricing between different retailers we checked out similar items at each company. For this review, we looked at the price range for all baseball memorabilia and the price range for NFL jerseys. While we usually also check out the prices in sales sections, Press Pass Collectibles didn't have a dedicated sale section. Here is how the prices shake out:
- MLB memorabilia: $4.99 to $119,999.99. This includes an unsigned historical photo of an umpire up to a set of signed baseball cards from the first MLB HOF class.
- NFL jerseys: $39.99 to $14,999.99. This includes a regular jersey for the Browns up to a Raiders jersey signed by Jerry Rice from 2001.
Trustworthy memorabilia
One of the standout aspects of Press Pass Collectibles is their trustworthiness and professionalism. The company's recent acquisition of long-term, exclusive rights to Magic Johnson memorabilia speaks volumes about its credibility and legitimacy. Since nearly every product they offer bears an autograph, customers can rest assured that they are investing in genuine and authentic items. Press Pass Collectibles uses third-party companies to authenticate all of its items to eliminate concerns about counterfeit products.
21-day limited returns
If, for any reason, you need to return a purchased item, Press Pass Collectibles provides a 21-day return window. Unfortunately, this isn't without penalties. Customers are responsible for return shipping costs, which will take a dent out of your return money. On top of that Press Pass Collectibles requires a 20% restocking fee. So, if you're hoping to get your money back, you might want to keep the fees in mind before you buy.
Missing reviews from third-party sites
Press Pass Collectibles has a solid reputation with the Better Business Bureau. The site holds an impressive "A+" rating. However, in terms of customer ratings on verified third-party sites, Press Pass Collectibles falls behind. During our research, we had trouble finding any third-party review sites that had any feedback from customers. This is one of the main factors that kept Press Pass Collectibles from the top spot on our list.
Solid option for huge inventory
The extensive collection at Press Pass Collectibles is filled with thousands of autographed products, guaranteeing that you'll stumble upon unique items that could become cherished pieces of your collection. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a casual enthusiast, we highly recommend exploring Press Pass Collectibles for your next sports memorabilia purchase. Their commitment to authenticity and their impressive inventory have earned them a fairly high rating in this review. With some concerns like expensive returns and a lack of user reviews on third-party sites, it doesn't quite reach the top spot. But if you're looking for a wide inventory, Press Pass Collectibles is still totally worth your time. Just make sure you pick out something you really want so you don't need to worry about their return fees.
Sports Integrity
- Prices for MLB: $9.99 - $69,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys: $99 - $1,799.99
- Options to buy vintage items
- Returns available within 14 days
- Free shipping on $199+
- Third-party authentication
- 200% refund for authentication guarantee
- "A+" rating from the BBB
Sports Integrity offers an inventory of various sports memorabilia categories, encompassing football, baseball, basketball, hockey, entertainment, cases, and boxing. However, it's worth noting that they offer limited to no products for categories that may be of lesser interest to collectors, such as horse racing, soccer, tennis, and wrestling. The company touts daily additions to its inventory, but it's apparent that these items have a brief shelf life. This could be attributed to their relatively slimmer product selection or the rapid depletion of stock.
Site could use some updates
At first glance, the site for Sports Integrity is a solid design. They've got good navigation with dropdown menus and well-organized products. On its homepage, Sports Integrity highlights a new product weekly, presenting it with multiple photos and an accompanying explanation detailing why the featured item deserves special attention. However, there are a few places where the site has fallen behind. For example, the blog hasn't seen updates for over a year, suggesting it may not be currently active. On top of that, some pages yield no results due to products presumably selling out quickly.
Solid inventory with competitive prices
In terms of pricing, we found that the sports memorabilia offered by Sports Integrity is generally in line with what competitors offer. In particular, we loved seeing options for new and vintage items here, which offers a good mix with a range of prices. To take a closer look at the pricing, we looked at the prices for two categories: baseball memorabilia and signed NFL jerseys. While we usually check out the sales prices too, there wasn't a dedicated sales section at Sports Integrity. So, we just checked out two popular categories. The prices at Sports Integrity shake out to:
- MLB memorabilia: $9.99 for a stadium pin - $69,999.99 for a baseball signed by Babe Ruth.
- NFL signed jerseys: $99 for a jersey signed by Darius Slay Jr. - $1,799.99 for a jersey signed by Patrick Mahomes.
14-day returns and free shipping on $199+
Customers can enjoy free shipping on orders exceeding $199, though this only includes customers who live in the United States. However, customers need to be aware that Sports Integrity's return policy is much stricter than some of its competitors. Customers only have a 14-day window to initiate returns. On top of that, all of the items must be unused and in their original condition to qualify for a full refund.
Ironclad authenticity guarantee
Sports Integrity is all about authenticity, and the company wants you to know it. Sports Integrity backs its products with a tamper-proof hologram and a Certificate of Authenticity for each hand-signed collectible. The retailer goes the extra mile by participating in private and public autograph sessions with athletes across the country so that all of the items sold by Sports Integrity have been signed in person for full authenticity. Plus, Sports Integrity offers third-party authentication options like Beckett (BAS), PSA DNA, and JSA (Spence) to make extra sure. In fact, they're so confident that they provide the Sports Integrity IRONCLAD Guarantee, promising a 200% refund if an item fails authentication by PSA, JSA, or Beckett.
Strong ratings from happy customers
According to our research, Sports Integrity is living up to its name. The company has a top-tier rating of "A+" with the Better Business Bureau. Further, Sports Integrity also holds a full 5-star rating from the BBB. Outside of that, Sports Integrity holds up with customers also. On average, across multiple review sites, customers have given Sports Integrity a 4.6-star average out of 5. The reviews praise Sports Integrity for high-quality items coming in perfect condition, quick shipping, and all the promised authentication materials ready to go.
Top option for vintage finds
In general Sports Integrity is a solid option. While the company doesn't have quite as many memorabilia options as some of its competitors, it's a solid option for cost and trustworthiness, which is a huge bonus. We were particularly impressed with the 200% refund guarantee if the authentication of any item sold by Sports Integrity fails at any of their third-party authentication partners. We love a company that stands behind its products, and with some options in our review being less than trustworthy, Sports Integrity shows up the competition. While its limited inventory keeps it out of the top two, it's still a solid choice, especially if you want a mix of new and vintage memorabilia.
Sports Memorabilia
- Prices for MLB memorabilia from $19.99 to $1,425,459.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $19.99 to $454,549.99
- Sale prices from $3.99 to $1,399.99
- Holographic authentication
- Returns within 30 days
- Free shipping on $49+
- "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB
Sports Memorabilia is another company in this review with a familiar owner: Fanatics. Given this, Sports Memorabilia shares many of its products with the Fanatics website and its other affiliated sister companies.
Competitive pricing
The pricing at Sports Memorabilia is quite competitive, putting them on par with other market players. However, it's challenging to pinpoint what sets Sports Memorabilia apart from the competition. Unlike some of its rivals who also dabble in celebrity memorabilia, Sports Memorabilia exclusively focuses on sports-related collectibles, which doesn't help it stand out as well as some of its competitors.
Clean site design mirrors sister sites
Sports Memorabilia offers all the staples of sports gear and autographed items like photos, helmets, jerseys, framed photos, inscribed items, and trading cards. Navigating their extensive product inventory of over 9,000 items is made easy with user-friendly search options. In fact, Sports Memorabilia is very similar in styling, design, and functionality to its parent site, Fanatics Authentic.
Unique one-of-a-kind items with competitive prices
With tons of different sports available, you can find almost anything at Sports Memorabilia. In order to get a solid comparison between Sports Memorabilia and other retailers in this review, we checked out the pricing in three different categories: Autographed MLB merchandise, autographed NFL jerseys, and the price ranges for clearance or sale items. Here's a quick look at what you can expect from Sports Memorabilia:
- MLB autographed memorabilia: $19.99 to $1,425,459.99. This includes items from a Sun Sox baseball card to a one-of-a-kind signed baseball from Josh Gibson.
- NFL autographed jerseys: $19.99 to $454,549.99. This includes items from a worn jersey card to a signed jersey worn by Michael Jordan.
- Sale items: $3.99 to $1,399.99. This includes items from a photo (unsigned) of a football player to a game-used hockey stick.
Includes holographic authentication
Every item offered at Sports Memorabilia comes with a hologram authentication that's as unique as a unicorn in a tutu. Want to make sure your memorabilia is the real deal? Just enter the code from your hologram tag in their on-site checker. The stickers are tamper-proof, so if someone tries to copy them, the authenticator will just fall apart. That way you can be sure you're getting the real thing every time.
Shipping is free on orders $49+
The prices for shipping are something that changes regularly at Sports Memorabilia. If you catch it at the right time, you can get a great deal on shipping at this site. For example, at the time of this review, all orders over $49 were eligible for free shipping. And, if you need to make a return for any reason, customers can send back items to Sports Memorabilia within 30 days of their purchase date.
Solid scores, but some concerning reviews
Based on the reviews, Sports Memorabilia is definitely a place to check out. According to the Better Business Bureau, the retailer has a stellar score. With an "A+" rating, accreditation, and 4.2 out of 5 stars on the BBB, Sports Memorabilia stands out among the crowd for its positive ratings. And it doesn't stop there. When we checked out Sports Memorabilia on third-party review sites, it was even better. The average star rating is 4.8 out of 5. However, when we dug into the reviews, it was a little alarming to see that many of the recent ones are talking about items that customers never received or hologram codes that weren't valid. So, while the reputation is good overall, and customers do praise the service representatives at Sports Memorabilia, one of the other sites may still be more trustworthy to be safe.
Missing something special
In the grand scheme of sports memorabilia retailers, Sports Memorabilia is a solid choice in terms of selection and prices. However, there isn't anything that particularly sets them apart or makes them a top choice over higher-rated competitors. Most of their products can also be found on their sister sites or through other competing retailers. Nevertheless, collectors are likely to stumble upon some excellent additions to their collections here. However, for those seeking a retailer with a more extensive and unique range of products, our top-rated sports memorabilia retailer remains the better choice.
Fan's Edge
- Prices for MLB from 1.39 to $99,999.99
- Prices for NFL from $3.99 to $24,999.99
- Sale prices from $0.99 to $262.49
- Options to buy vintage items
- Returns within 365 days
- 30% off deal
- "A+" rating from the BBB
Back in 2012, Fan's Edge changed up its game when it was acquired by its competitor (and another top-rated retailer in this review), Fanatics Authentic. Since then, the two have operated hand in hand, serving sports memorabilia enthusiasts with their unique offerings and user experiences.
Lots of classic sports equipment
Fan's Edge, while closely aligned with Fanatics, has carved out its own niche and established itself as a reliable destination for sports memorabilia, sporting a clean and professional website that caters to both seasoned collectors and newcomers alike. In general, the company sets itself apart through its "Throwback" category with tons of vintage options available.
Same site in different colors
First off, anyone who's used the sister site of Fan's Edge will recognize the design is almost exactly the same - just in another color scheme. In terms of product selection, Fan's Edge doesn't disappoint. You'll discover an extensive inventory featuring photos, blankets, trophies, balls, hats, banners, and an array of other sports-related items. With a product lineup closely mirroring that of Fanatics Authentic, it's a smart move to explore both websites to easily compare prices for specific products.
Extensive range of sports equipment
The website showcases an extensive range of sports memorabilia, covering NFL, NCAA, MLB, NBA, NHL, NASCAR, Soccer, and the Olympics, along with more specialized categories such as the US Open, UFC Fighting, Arena Football, MMA, WNBA, and much more. Navigating the Fan's Edge website is a breeze, thanks to its user-friendly design, straightforward category listings, and filters. It's worth noting that there are countdown timers on many of the listings, which appear to be countdowns to get the items at that particular price before the price changes.
Extensive range of sports equipment
As we mentioned before, Fan's Edge stands out for its dedication to preserving the nostalgia of sports through its "Throwback" category. This distinctive section allows sports memorabilia enthusiasts to dive into a treasure trove of vintage gear, featuring iconic brands, categories, and throwback teams like the Brooklyn Dodgers, New York Titans, and the Washington Senators. For those seeking memorabilia related to retired legends, Fan's Edge offers a curated list of top retired athletes too.
Fewer autographed items and more gear
When it comes to pricing, Fan's Edge aligns closely with its parent brand, Fanatics Authentic. It's worth noting that this competitive pricing dynamic between the two brands may be orchestrated by Fanatics Authentic to maximize revenue for either platform. To compare prices between Fan's Edge and other retailers in this review, we checked out three common items: MLB items, NFL items, and the pricing for items on sale for College Sports at Fan's Edge. It's important to note that not as many of the items are signed by players as the items offered by its sister site. The prices shake out accordingly:
- MLB Memorabilia: $1.39 to $99,999.99 with the items ranging from a stadium booklet to a jersey for Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels that was used in a game
- NFL Memorabilia: $3.99 to $$24,999.99 with items ranging from a Carolina Panthers stadium pin to a Tom Brady Tampa Bay Buccaneers autographed jersey
- Sale College Sports items: $0.99 to $262.49 with the items ranging from a magic towel with a sports team printed on it to a golf bag from Notre Dame
365-day returns
Fan's Edge boasts a generous 365-day return policy, offering customers flexibility and peace of mind when making purchases. Should you need to return an item, you can conveniently obtain a shipping return label from their website for a nominal fee of $9.99, making returns hassle-free. While Fan's Edge didn't have any free shipping options, they were offering a 30% off sale at the time of this review, so it's worth it to check in from time to time to see if the site has new promotions.
Reviewers warn customers to stay away
While Fan's Edge has some top-quality features, it falls behind its sister company a little in the reviews department. While the company holds a solid "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, Fan's Edge isn't as popular with reviewers on third-party sites. According to reviews on Sitejabber and Trustpilot, customers have given Fan's Edge an average rating of 1.7 stars out of 5. Customers complained about being sent the wrong items and being unable to get a hold of customer service when other problems arose. Customers have also recently complained that the items (when they do arrive) are in poor condition or don't look like they were promised in the promo photos. Overall, there are hundreds of reviews warning customers to stay away from Fan's Edge.
Good, but not better than its sister site
In conclusion, Fan's Edge seems like a mostly solid choice, but when you compare the reviews at Fan's Edge to companies with higher ratings, it doesn't stand out as well. That, plus fewer autographed items than at its sister site, makes Fan's Edge a solid middle-ground option overall. While the product range closely aligns with Fanatics Authentic, it's beneficial to explore both that platform and Fan's Edge to make sure you're getting the best deals on your desired memorabilia. However, if it's autographs you're after, this won't be the top option for you.
Gameday Sports Memorabilia
- Prices for MLB form $15 to $3,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $69.99- $2,999.99
- Autographed inventory across the board
- Authenticity Guarantee
- Returns within 30 days
- "A+" rating from the BBB
If you're on the hunt for authentic autographed sports gear, Gameday Sports Memorabilia should be one of your first stops. With a fantastic authenticity guarantee for their products, you can be sure that each autograph is totally legit.
Every product is autographed
What sets Gameday apart is that every product they offer proudly bears the signature of a professional athlete: this way collectors always receive genuine memorabilia. In the realm of pricing, Gameday Sports Memorabilia proves to be a competitive player, standing toe-to-toe with companies that offer similar autographed items, and even offering standout items at much lower costs in some cases.
Good UI, but design needs updating
Navigating the Gameday Sports Memorabilia website is a breeze, thanks to its user-friendly design. Whether you're using their efficient search function or exploring their well-organized product categories, you'll find the inventory to be transparent and accessible. The sports categories on offer encompass a wide range, including NFL, MLB, NCAA, NBA, NHL, Soccer, Olympics, Boxing, Golf, and Wrestling.
Wealth of sub categories
Within each of these categories, you'll discover a variety of sub-categories, featuring autographed cards, jerseys, photos, mini helmets, and more. This thoughtful categorization helps you quickly identify the types of products they carry. However, it's worth noting that some categories may occasionally appear empty. And the company uses images that don't fit the sizing of the website which contributes to a slapdash feeling that doesn't immediately say "high quality" to customers.
Great prices for autographed items
There's a huge inventory of items at Gameday Sports Memorabilia. In particular, the company is a top choice for autographed items. In fact, other than display cases and other necessities that weren't actual memorabilia, it's hard to find items that aren't autographed. To get a clear idea of how the pricing at Gameday Sports Memorabilia stacks up against other companies in this review, we checked out the price ranges in two categories: autographed MLB items and autographed NFL jerseys. At other companies, we also looked at sale items, but there wasn't a dedicated sale section at Gameday Sports Memorabilia, so we left that one out of the comparison.
What kind of pricing acan you expect?
Here's the pricing you can expect from this retailer:
- Autographed MLB items: $15 to $3,999.99. This includes products from a Lou Boudreau Autographed Photo to a Boston Red Sox Ted Williams Autographed Framed White 1939 Jersey
- Autographed NFL jerseys: $69.99- $2,999.99. This includes products from a Chicago Bears Jordan Howard Autographed Blue Jersey to a Chicago Bears jersey autographed by Walter Payton & Jim McMahon
Authenticity guarantee
One great feature we loved was that Gameday Sports Memorabilia offers an authenticity guarantee with every item. Every hand-signed collectible they offer includes a tamper-evident hologram and a certificate of authenticity. These holograms have unique serial numbers, allowing buyers to easily trace their purchases. Gameday Sports Memorabilia uses third-party authentication companies such as PSA/DNA, James Spence Authentication (JSA), Beckett Authentication Services (BAS), Upper Deck Authenticated, Mill Creek Sports, and Schwartz Sports to validate all their items.
Returns within 30 days
If, for any reason, you need to return an item, Gameday Sports Memorabilia provides a hassle-free process. Within 30 days, customers can initiate a return by logging into their account, accessing their order, and selecting the "Return Items" option. As long as the authenticity certificate is returned within the timeframe, customers will have no problem getting their money back. However, it's worth noting that the site doesn't specify if the customer is responsible for return shipping or not.
Popular with the BBB
Gameday Sports Memorabilia enjoys a stellar reputation, holding an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. Their customer-centric approach and commitment to authenticity contribute to their solid standing in the industry. The only reputation drawback to this company is that it isn't popular with third-party review sites. Customers have left a handful of reviews for Gameday Sports Memorabilia on Facebook, but there aren't many comments out there talking about experiences buying items there. So, we'll have to rely on the BBB rating to get a picture of Gameday Sports Memorabilia's reputation.
Great for autographed gear
Gameday Sports Memorabilia is a trusted and reputable choice for collectors looking for authentic autographed sports memorabilia. The gear is fantastic and not too expensive (even for signed football jerseys from famous pro players). However, one potential drawback is that some customers may seek retro jerseys or other gear without athlete signatures, a category where Gameday Sports Memorabilia doesn't really carry inventory. If that's what you're after, we recommend exploring our top-rated site, which offers a mix of both autographed and non-autographed sports gear.
ASG Memorabilia
- Prices for MLB from $49.99 to $4,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $79.99 to $9,999.99
- New auction options
- Fully authenticated items
- Returns within 30 days
- "A+" rating from the BBB
ASG Memorabilia bills itself as your ticket to iconic sports moments. They're not only a treasure trove for sports enthusiasts but also have a unique charity auction platform in the works.
Authenticity is paramount
ASG takes pride in guaranteeing the authenticity of all their memorabilia, whether obtained in person or backed by tamper-proof identification stickers and certificates of authenticity. Whether you're preparing for a charity auction or aiming to add a personal touch to your sports collection with your favorite athlete's signature, ASG is here to make sure you can proudly showcase those memorable sports moments.
Clean site design with easy browsing
Browsing the ASG Memorabilia website is a breeze, thanks to its user-friendly interface. The company offers super-organized product sections, and an easy-to-navigate inventory and search bar. The sports categories span NFL, MLB, NCAA, NBA, NHL, Soccer, Golf, Horse Racing, and more, each featuring various sub-categories such as autographed cards, jerseys, photos, and helmets for quick product identification. On top of that ASG has a standout feature: auctions. For people or organizations who want to auction off memorabilia, ASG facilitates that process for them at no extra cost, and the site makes it easy to get started with just a few clicks.
Less inventory than competitors
In terms of inventory, there are hundreds of options available at ASG Memorabilia. However, compared to the thousands of options available at other retailers, this feels a little small. Still, while researching prices we found that at least ASG provides some unique options that aren't available at other retailers.
Price comparison
Now, for the price comparison, we looked at the prices for all autographed MLB items and for NFL autographed jerseys. We weren't able to check out the sale prices at ASG Memorabilia since this retailer doesn't have a dedicated sale or discount page. That considered, here are the prices you can expect from ASG Memorabilia:
- MLB autographed items: $49.99 to $4,999.99. This includes items from a baseball autographed by Joe Panik to a jersey that's been autographed by Tom Brady and David Ortiz.
- NFL autographed jerseys: $79.99 to $9,999.99. This includes items from a Bears jersey autographed by Anthony Thomas to an autographed Patriots Jersey from a championship game.
One thing to note with ASG is that with a smaller inventory, the store is more focused, but the prices start higher here than at other retailers.
All items are authentic
A certificate of authenticity is offered by ASG to validate their products. They exclusively collaborate with top-tier companies so that each certificate of authenticity includes a tamper-proof sticker unique to the item, accompanied by a matching card with a corresponding serial number. This serial number is then integrated into third-party databases, making it effortless for buyers to verify the authenticity of the memorabilia they purchase. ASG Memorabilia works with industry leaders like Beckett, JSA, PSA, and Upper Deck to authenticate each item to the highest industry standards.
30-day returns
ASG Memorabilia offers a 30-day return policy, granting you a month after receiving your item to initiate a return. To qualify, the item must remain in its original condition, unused, with tags, and in the original packaging, plus your proof of purchase. If the return meets the criteria, a return shipping label and detailed instructions will be sent to you right away. The company doesn't note any extra charge for returns, which is a bonus compared to many companies in this review.
Missing reviews online
One drawback to ASG Memorabilia is that the company isn't super popular online. While there is a page for ASG Memorabilia at the Better Business Bureau, with an "A+" rating, any further details about the company are scarce. There aren't any third-party reviews from the usual sites like Trustpilot and Sitejabber. While the site does have six 5-star reviews on Facebook, this isn't the greatest way to tell if the company is worth shopping with or not. So, given the ambiguous nature of the company's reputation, it slid down the ratings just a bit.
Mid-tier service overall
While things like online auctions might be a draw for people looking to sell items, ASG Memorabilia doesn't have a lot of other standout features. Their inventory is lower than other sites in this review, and the prices start higher too. You can find some solid and unique items on the site, so it might be worth a look, but with almost no review presence online, this site settles just above the middle of the pack. If you want something more, definitely check out one of our top-rated options instead.
Total Sports Enterprises
- Prices for MLB baseballs approx: $2.99- $1,282.59
- Prices for NFL jerseys approx: $62.69 to $815.39
- All Pittsburgh teams
- Returns available within 30 days
- Third-party authentication
- "A+" rating from the BBB
If you're looking for a site with the most options online, Total Sports Enterprises immediately falls short. With fewer sports than most competitors, and fewer inventory items in the categories they do have, this site falls behind in almost every category.
Not a reseller
There is a good reason for this, however: Total Sports Enterprises is not a reseller. Instead, the company serves as the sole provider of certified genuine autographed memorabilia for various athletes, encompassing those from the Pittsburgh Steelers, Pittsburgh Pirates, Pittsburgh Penguins, and Minnesota Vikings. Almost all the signed memorabilia they offer has been personally signed during their events, whether public signings, private signings, shared signings, or signings at major shows. In cases where an item wasn't signed in their presence, it was obtained through trusted partners and validated by a third-party authenticator.
Site could use a little facelift
While there's nothing majorly wrong with the site design, it does feel a little out of date compared to some of the sleek and modern sites we've seen across our reviews. Some things like blurry photos or pages that don't have enough text on them or feel unfinished pop up across the site. The actual browsing is okay, with the options laid out clearly in the top navigation with drop-down menus and filters during shopping, but the overall effect is that the company could spruce up the site a bit.
Pittsburgh-focused inventory
For an inventory that focuses primarily on Pittsburgh teams, Total Sports Enterprises definitely stands out from the pack. Unfortunately, this limited inventory does cut out a significant number of sports enthusiasts. But, if you're a die-hard fan of a Pittsburgh-based team, this might be the stop for you.
Competitive pricing
To compare the prices at Total Sports Enterprises with other retailers in this review, we checked out two price ranges: the total price range for MLB memorabilia and the price range for NFL autographed jerseys. You can expect prices at Total Sports Enterprises to look like:
- MLB memorabilia: $2.99 for a toothbrush to $1,282.59 for a signed game stub
- NFL autographed jerseys: $62.69 for a Mike Wagner signed jersey to $815.39 for a John Stallworth signed jersey
It's worth noting that most of the inventory at Total Sports Enterprises is modern. So, if you're looking for vintage items, you might need to shop elsewhere.
Guaranteed authentication with holograms
Total Sports Enterprises guarantees that all of its items are 100% authentic. As the majority of its autographed memorabilia was obtained during signings it organized or took part in, only a handful of items even come from outside the company. For those items, Total Sports Enterprises has the inventory reviewed by a third party to authenticate the signatures. Its commitment to authenticity is backed by tamper-proof holograms from TSE or Beckett, each linked to a database for easy verification, offering the buyer confidence in the genuineness of its purchases.
Returns valid within 30 days
The return policy at Total Sports Enterprises allows for merchandise to be returned to the warehouse within 30 days from the item's shipment date. There are a few conditions such as the items need to be unworn/unused and include the original tags, labels, and packaging. However, customized items are considered final sale and cannot be returned. When using the provided return label, a $9.99 deduction covers return shipping costs, but the company will bear this charge if the return is due to an error on its part.
Light on reviews but solid BBB score
Like a few others in this review, Total Sports Enterprises isn't the most popular with reviewers. Keep in mind, it actually has pretty good scores with a 4.1-star average, but the reviews are few and far between. Through our research, we could only find reviews for Total Sports Enterprises on Facebook. There just weren't any hits on major third-party review sites. On the bright side, Total Sports Enterprises does have a solid "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, highlighting its solid reputation there. However, we would like to see more third-party reviews.
Pretty much only for Pittsburgh
If you're a die-hard Pittsburgh sports fan, this site is going to be your jam. It's got all the major teams and mostly sells items the site has seen signed in person. However, if you're a fan of any teams outside of Pittsburgh, you're pretty much out of luck. For this reason, Total Sports Enterprises only gets a 2.5-star rating. This is primarily due to the fact that as a retailer of sports memorabilia, it doesn't serve the majority of sports fans or sports teams, which is a huge letdown. While prices are solid and the inventory has nice modern items, it just misses the mark if you're not a Pittsburgh fan.
Steiner Sports
- Prices for MLB memorabilia from $19.99 to $1,425,459.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys from $19.99 to $454,549.99
- Sale prices from $3.99 to $1,399.99
- Holographic authentication
- Returns within 30 days
- Free shipping on $49+
Steiner Sports is a go-to destination for all things sports memorabilia. They offer a wide array of collectibles, from autographed balls, trading cards, and jerseys, to display cases and hats.
Sister sites in our review
If you're thinking "this looks familiar" you would be right. Steiner Sports is another company under the ownership of Fanatics Authentic and shares many of its product offerings with sister sites that cater to similar tastes. However, given the striking resemblances between these sports memorabilia giants, it becomes a tad challenging to discern what sets Steiner Sports apart from the rest, or to come up with a reason why any shopper should choose this retailer over its competitors.
Site helps you stay informed on sports
It's not just the inventory that is similar, Steiner Sports also sports almost the same site design and functionality as its sister sites. One difference that does stand out at Steiner Sports is the spotlight at the bottom of the page that shows the leading teams and players across various sports leagues, including the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, UFC, golf, and more. While the presentation might appear somewhat text-heavy, it serves as a convenient and quick reference for sports enthusiasts looking to stay updated on relevant events and explore related memorabilia to enrich their collections. It offers an easy-to-digest overview that's beneficial for staying in the know about the latest happenings in the sports world.
Same inventory as sister site
The cost of each product at Steiner Sports fluctuates considerably, contingent on factors such as its age, the signature it bears, and the type of product itself. To compare prices between Steiner Sports and other reviewed retailers, we analyzed the range of prices within three distinct shopping categories: autographed MLB merchandise, autographed NFL jerseys, and the pricing of clearance or discounted items. Here's a brief overview of what you can anticipate when shopping at Steiner Sports:
- MLB autographed memorabilia: $19.99 to $1,425,459.99. This includes items from a Sun Sox baseball card to a signed baseball from Josh Gibson. Notably, these are the exact same items sold by Sports Memorabilia.
- NFL autographed jerseys: $19.99 to $454,549.99. This includes items from a worn jersey card to a signed jersey worn by Michael Jordan. Again, these are precisely the same items as the sister site.
- Sale items: $3.99 to $1,399.99. This includes items from a photo (unsigned) of a football player to a game-used hockey stick. Unsurprisingly, these are also the same items that were seen at Sports Memorabilia at the time of this review.
Bottom line? The inventory at Steiner Sports isn't just similar to its sister site, it's almost completely identical.
Unique hologram authentication
Each product available at Steiner Sports includes a one-of-a-kind hologram authentication feature. To confirm the authenticity of your memorabilia, simply input the code found on your hologram tag into their online verification tool. These hologram stickers are designed to be tamper-proof, so any attempt to duplicate them will result in the authenticator's disintegration.
Free shipping on $49+ and 30-day returns
Steiner Sports periodically runs site-wide sales, offering enticing discounts and free shipping once you reach a specific spending threshold. For example, the offer at the time of this review was free shipping on orders $49+. Generally, the pricing, whether during sales events or regular times, closely aligns with those of competing sites, occasionally even matching them identically. Another matching feature at Steiner Sports is its return window, which is identical to its sister site Sports Memorabilia. For customers' peace of mind, the return policy grants a 30-day window for returns, provided that the products remain unused and in their original condition.
BBB says "yikes" to Steiner Sports
While Steiner Sports is similar to its sister sites in most aspects, its reputation isn't one of them. Unfortunately, Steiner Sports only holds a "D-" rating from the Better Business Bureau, which isn't very encouraging. While ratings on third-party review sites are a little bit better with an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5, there are only a handful of reviews to back up this rating. In general, the positive comments focus on the customer support, and not the items themselves, which raises some questions about why there aren't more positive reviews about the actual purchases.
Not unique enough to make up for low ratings
Steiner Sports undoubtedly offers an extensive selection of sports memorabilia that can delight avid collectors. However, the inventory includes many of the products available at other retailers, going so far as to be identical in many cases to its sister sites. Basically, there isn't a compelling reason to favor Steiner Sports over most other retailers we've reviewed. Given this fact and the low scores from the BBB, we recommend beginning your sports memorabilia shopping journey with our top-rated retailers, where you're likely to find a more unique and wide-ranging selection of products.
Sports Collectibles
- Prices for MLB baseballs approx: $64 to $336.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys approx: $104 to $879.99
- Options to buy vintage items
- Returns available
- Free shipping on $100+
- Third-party authentication
- "A" rating from the BBB
Sports Collectibles boasts an extensive collection of authentic sports memorabilia, encompassing a wide array of categories, including the NFL, NHL, NCAA, MLB, NBA, golf, wrestling, boxing, soccer, and the Olympics. Impressively, they venture into unique territories with product categories like horse racing, tennis, CFL, politics, movies, TV, and music memorabilia. However, in comparison to certain competitors, it's evident that Sports Collectibles exhibits a relatively narrower product selection in some areas.
Site could use an update
Navigating the website at Sports Collectibles is a straightforward process, but unlike many competitors, Sports Collectibles doesn't offer hover-over drop-down menu categories. So, this makes the process of looking through options much more time-consuming. Unfortunately, the limitations become apparent as certain categories, such as movie memorabilia, golf pin flags, or NBA memorabilia for home decor, yield zero results, which means customers may have gone through the trouble of digging through the Sports Collectible categories only to end up with no products in the section they wanted to shop from. The most annoying missing feature? There's no pricing filter to organize the inventory, making it hard to scroll through hundreds of products at a time.
Inventory searches were confusing and prices all over
When we checked out the pricing at Sports Collectibles, we ran into some of the navigation problems mentioned above. You can't just browse the entire inventory of a category. So while we usually look at the entire MLB category for price comparisons, we had to select one item, so we went with signed baseballs from the MLB. On top of that, we also checked out the prices for jerseys from the NFL. However, since there's no price filter, the price ranges for this site are approximate. Unfortunately, like a few other retailers in this review, Sports Collectibles doesn't have a dedicated sale section, so we didn't include sales in our price comparison. At the time of our review, the prices at Sports Collectibles looked like this:
- MLB signed baseballs: $64 to $336.99
- NFL jerseys: $104 to $879.99
Authentication guarantee
Sports Collectibles emphasizes their commitment to authentic products, asserting that their offerings are genuine, whereas other companies may be peddling knock-offs. Each purchase comes with a certification card to show that a third-party certification process has been completed to authenticate all of the items at Sports Collectibles.
Free shipping on $100+ but poor return policy
There are some deals for shipping and returns at Sports Collectibles, though they're not as impressive as some of the offers at competitors. For example, free shipping is available through Sports Collectibles on purchases of $100+; otherwise, a flat-rate shipping charge of $9.95 applies. For returns, Sports Collectibles unfortunately lacks clarity overall. Details regarding the timeframe for returns are absent from their website, and there's also a 15% restocking fee for all returned items, which makes initiating returns a less-than-ideal option if customers are unhappy with the items they purchased.
Red flags with Sports Collectibles
The Better Business Bureau has given Sports Collectibles a solid "A" , indicating a pretty solid reputation. Nevertheless, some customers have voiced concerns about finding identical products available at cheaper prices on third-party websites. Plus, Sports Collectibles doesn't have the greatest ratings with customers in general. The average rating for Sports Collectibles is about 2 stars out of 5 across different review sites. Customers have complained that the site steals listings from stores like eBay, trying to make money on a listing without the seller's permission. Further, some customers have complained that they received items that weren't fully authenticated, which is a huge red flag.
Too many concerns for safe shopping
The bottom line for Sports Collectibles is that there just isn't a standout quality that helps Sports Collectibles compete with other memorabilia companies. With a frustrating user interface as well as complaints from customers about items being sold without permission or items missing authentication, there are more than a few red flags that suggest you might want to look elsewhere for your sports memorabilia. Our advice? Check out the top-rated sites for options with solid reputations and more trustworthy sales practices.
